In this kat’s quest to bring you the latest health and nutrition news, I’ve
come across something y’all might find interesting. It concerns the possible
connection diet soda may have with heart disease and diabetes.
Yep, you read right. That innocent pink can of Tab you’re swigging may
mess with your ticker. Or lead you unwittingly down the road to diabetes.
Some of you hardcore health junkies may remember hearing about the
results of a study in the July 2007 edition of the American Heart
Association's journal, Circulation.
The paper, “Soft Drink Consumption and
Risk of Developing Cardiometabolic Risk Factors and the Metabolic Syndrome
in Middle-Aged Adults in the Community,” found people who drank one or more
diet sodas each day developed the same risks for heart disease as those who
consumed sugar-laden soda. This shocked researchers, who expected to see
some difference between regular and diet soda.
Part of what the study concluded was people who drank one or more sodas
(diet or full-octane) a day had an increased risk of developing metabolic
syndrome compared to those who rarely drank soda. Metabolic
syndrome is a constellation of symptoms that increases the risk for heart
disease and diabetes. Signs of this metabolic nightmare include bulging
waistlines along with higher blood pressure, blood sugar, cholesterol, and
triglyceride readings.
The research for the paper came from a huge, multi-generational heart
study observing residents of Framingham, Massachusetts. It’s important to
note that the Framingham studies are some of the most revered in medical
circles. Since 1948 they’ve followed as many as three living generations of
families and their cardiovascular health.
To illustrate the study’s
influence, before Framingham cigarette smoking was not considered a major
contributor to heart disease. The Framingham Heart Study’s goal is to
identify the common factors contributing to cardiovascular disease (CVD) by
following its development over long periods of time. They use very large
groups of participants who haven’t developed CVD symptoms or suffered a
heart attack or stroke.
Barry Popkin, University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill, who has argued
for a surgeon general warning on soda, said the study’s results aren't
really surprising. He said diet sodas are usually marketed to people who
already lead unhealthy lives and know they need to change their dietary
choices. This means many people drinking diet sodas are more likely to have
unhealthy habits that could lead to increased heart disease risks exclusive
of their diet soda consumption.
To say this study got the beverage industry’s bloomers in a bunch would
be an understatement. Here’s what Susan Neeley, president of the American
Beverage Association, said, “How can something with zero calories that's 99
percent water with a little flavoring in it cause weight gain?" she said.
While Ms. Neeley has a point, the larger issue will probably be
the behavioral component attached to diet beverage consumption that ends up
implicating her industry, whether that’s a fair thing or not.
This kat is left pondering several things:
1) The fact that two separate studies are now showing some connection
between heart disease, pre-diabetic conditions, and diet soda suggests
there’s probably something to think about here. A more current paper from a
different team in January 2008 supports the original study’s findings. Which
is, again, the knowledge that people who drink liters of diet soda a day are
probably also having trouble moderating their intake of other foods.
2) There is undoubtedly more research (even the researchers agree) that
needs to be done before drawing any hard conclusions about diet soda and
disease.
3) The jury is still out on aspartame. While some may seem to have no
problems, others contend it is not the miracle sweetener food companies
would have you think it is.
I hope this information helps all you humans remember to grab some
POW (plain old water) the next time the urge to pound down Diet Pepsi
overtakes you.
So, until next time this is your favorite feline wishing all my adoring
fans nothing but blessings and may “the Devil take the hindmost.” Sorry, to
bring religion into this, but the Kat is a wee worried about his feline soul
after shining a light on the large soda companies. Or Big Fizz, as I call
them.
You do know they have hit squads, don’t you? Why do you think they call
their product pop?